Tannenbaum Helpern Syracuse & Hirschtritt, LLP
About Us Careers Contact Us Search
Home Practice Areas Industries Case Results Attorneys Publications Events Press Room

NY Court of Appeals Upholds Commercial Tenant's Yellowstone Injunction Waiver

Click here to download PDF

In February 2018, we reported on the decision of the New York Appellate Division, Second Department, in 159 MP Corp. v. Redbridge Bedford, LLC, 160 AD 3d 176 (2d Dept 2018), which ruled that a tenant's waiver in a commercial lease of its right to file an action for a declaratory judgment and apply for a Yellowstone injunction is not contrary to public policy and is enforceable.

On May 7, 2019, a sharply divided Court of Appeals affirmed this ruling - effectively putting an end to Yellowstone injunctions. By a vote of four to three, with the majority and dissenting opinions spanning 48 pages, the Court shifted the balance of power between commercial landlords and their tenants in the State of New York, by giving landlords the right to require tenants to agree in the lease to a waiver of the tenant's right to file a declaratory judgment action and seek a Yellowstone injunction.

For over 50 years, First National Stores, Inc. v. Yellowstone Shopping Center, Inc., 21 N.Y.2d 630, 290 N.Y.S.2d 721 (1968) gave commercial tenants faced with a Notice to Cure from a landlord the absolute right to prevent the dispute from being litigated in Landlord/Tenant Court and freeze the status quo by stopping the clock on the time to cure the alleged default. A Tenant could simply file an action for a declaratory judgment in the Supreme Court. Typically, all the tenant had to show the Court was the existence of a Notice to Cure, and that the time to cure the alleged breach had not expired. There was no requirement that the tenant satisfy any of the usual standards for the issuance of a preliminary injunction, including "probable success on the merits." The Yellowstone injunction tolled the time to cure, prevented the landlord from commencing summary proceedings in Landlord/Tenant Court and often meant years of litigation in the Supreme Court.

In 159 MP Corp. v. Redbridge Bedford, LLC, 2019 N.Y. Slip Op. 03526, 2019 WL 1995526 (May 7, 2019), the Court of Appeals rejected the tenant's argument that the waiver should be unenforceable as a matter of public policy. After observing that the parties apparently had relatively equal bargaining power, the Court concluded that the waiver was enforceable. In simple terms, the Court changed the rules of the road by holding that commercial landlords can prevent tenants from filing Yellowstone actions by having the tenant agree in the lease that the tenant waives the right to file an action for a declaratory judgment.

Without the ability to seek a Yellowstone injunction, a tenant served with a Notice to Cure must cure within the time required under the lease or run the risk of an unalterable termination of the lease. More specifically, upon receipt of a Notice to Cure, the tenant will be placed in a difficult predicament. It must either (a) avoid the risk of losing the lease, by curing the default in question within the required time period at whatever the cost may be (even though the tenant may have real grounds to believe that no default exists) or (b) risk losing the lease by allowing the cure period to expire with the hope that the tenant can convince the Court in an eviction proceeding that no default exists.

One issue that was left unresolved is, irrespective of whether the right to a Yellowstone injunction has been waived, whether a commercial tenant can still argue that the cure period allowed under the lease is insufficient to permit the tenant to cure. Before 159 MP, a tenant could file an action for a declaratory judgment and ask for a Yellowstone injunction that would extend the time to cure. Moving forward, that right will be lost if the lease contains a Yellowstone waiver. In such event, the sole remedy available to the tenant is to raise the issue of insufficient time to cure as a defense in Landlord/Tenant Court.

Depending upon bargaining power, landlords may now consider having tenants agree to lease provisions under which tenants will waive their right to file declaratory judgment actions requesting Yellowstone injunctions and, thereby, forcing tenants to have alleged defaults determined in a summary eviction proceeding in Landlord/Tenant Court without the benefit of any toll on the tenants' time to cure. In response to such a Yellowstone waiver provision in a proposed lease, we anticipate, at a minimum, that a well-represented tenant will attempt to negotiate additional time to cure following a determination in a summary proceeding in Landlord/Tenant Court that a default does in fact exist.

159 MP is a game changer, which alters over 50 years of well-settled law. As noted in the dissenting opinion, it is now up to state lawmakers to enact legislation that would declare Yellowstone waivers unenforceable and provide tenants the right to file a declaratory judgment action seeking injunctive relief when a landlord serves a Notice to Cure. Until that time comes (and it may never come), the Yellowstone injunction is now dead in New York State!

For more information or if you have any questions regarding the topic discussed above, please contact Vincent Syracuse at syracuse@thsh.com, or Eric Schoenfeld at schoenfeld@thsh.com.

About Tannenbaum Helpern Syracuse & Hirschtritt LLP

Since 1978, Tannenbaum Helpern Syracuse & Hirschtritt LLP has combined a powerful mix of insight, creativity, industry knowledge, senior talent and transaction expertise to successfully guide clients through periods of challenge and opportunity. Our mission is to deliver the highest quality legal services in a practical and efficient manner, bringing to bear the judgment, common sense and expertise of well trained, business minded lawyers. Through our commitment to service and successful results, Tannenbaum Helpern continues to earn the loyalty of our clients and a reputation for excellence. For more information, visit www.thsh.com. Follow us on LinkedIn and Twitter: @THSHLAW.



Publications
BulletPoint
GlobalNote
Business Litigation Bulletin
Employment Notes
Note from the Real Estate Group
THSH E-Alert
Other Publications
Inclement Weather Policy
Other Publications Archive
President Obama Seeks to Broaden Overtime Protections for Employees
Privacy regulation in the United States
The Broad Scope of Franchise Laws: Traps for the Distribution Contract Drafter
Managing Distribution: How to Develop a Corporate Legal Compliance Program
Internet Distribution, E-Commerce and Other Computer Related Issues
Distribution Contracts
What Impact Will FATCA Have on Offshore Hedge Funds and How Should Such Funds Prepare for FATCA Compliance?
The American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012: What It Means to You
Privilege and the In-House Counsel: Protecting Your Communications Through Proper Registration and Careful Understanding
Are your digital communications protected by attorney-client privilege and what if privileged information is disclosed?
THSH Private Equity Roundtable Summary
Post Grant Review Under the America Invents Act
Bench-Bar Conversation with Justice Carolyn E. Demarest
Proposed Changes Set to Alter Estate and Gift Tax Structure in New York: Time to Make a Gift?
New York City Paid Sick Leave – What Staffing Firms Need to Know
New York State Estate and Gift Tax: The Hidden Costs of Tax Reform
Assessing Never-Examined SEC-Registered Investment Advisers: An SEC NEP Priority
Changes to NY Minimum Wage
NLRB Strikes Again
Bench-Bar Conversations with Justice Elizabeth Emerson
Attorney Professionalism Forum: What should an attorney do when the client wants to present false information and what happens
Reducing the risk of violating competition law
NY Rings in 2015 with a Minimum Wage Increase
Distribution & Agency 2015 - Q&A on the distribution of goods and services in 17 jurisdictions worldwide
Fair Chance Act
Sales Taxes on Construction Projects
Forget Big Brother, What Happens When it’s Opposing Counsel is Doing the Recording?
E-Discovery Identification & Preservation Guide For Lawyers (Version 2.0)
On the Horizon: What to do before selling your staffing business
Striking the Right Encryption Balance after FBI, Apple Fracas
Delaware Court Reiterates Need for Unambiguous Non-Reliance Provisions in M&A Agreements
Finalizing a Divorce? Wait, Just One More Thing …
IRS Proposed Changes to IRC 2704 Affect Business Succession and Estate Planning Valuation Discounts
Trump and the Estate Tax: What We Know
Actual-Intent Fraudulent Transfers and the Crime/Fraud Exception
Proposed NYS DFS Cybersecurity Regulations to Significantly Impact FS Companies
New Guidance for Human Resource Professionals to Avoid Antitrust Violations
Merger and Scènes à Faire: Two Defenses to Substantial Similarity in Copyright Litigation
What’s New in the Revised New York State Proposed Cybersecurity Regulation?
The Law of Insider Trading: A Primer For Investment Managers
Recent Cyber Attack On Law Firms Serves As A Wake-Up Call For Professional Services Firms
The Ambac Decision and the Future of the Common Interest Privilege Under the New York Law
Overview of Data Privacy and Cybersecurity Regulatory Landscape for Investment Advisers and Other Financial Services Companies
Global Ransomware Attack: Basic Security Measures Every Business Should Adopt
Distribution & Agency 2017- Q&A on the distribution of goods and services in 17 jurisdictions worldwide
New Copyright of Resource: Copyright Protection
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Using Per Diem Attorneys Plus An Addendum To The June Forum On Cybersecurity Ethics
Congressional Republicans Propose Sweeping Tax Reform
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Attorney-Client Confidentiality vs. the Customs Agent: Who Wins?
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Confidentiality Issues When Clients Don’t Tell The Truth
Rules for Equity Crowdfunding Effective May 16, 2016
Estate Planning Under Comprehensive Tax Reform
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Attorney Websites, Branding and Using Social Media
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Attorney Advertising And Self Promotion
NY Appellate Court Shifts Balance of Power in Commercial Real Estate Leases: Upholds Yellowstone Injunction Waiver
Recent Developments in Neighbor Litigation
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Communicating With Clients With Diminished Capacity
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Litigation Financing
Groundbreaking bipartisan Congressional Legislation could pave the way to fully legalized Marijuana
Conditions Precedents in Construction Contracts
Distribution & Agency 2018 - Q&A on the distribution of goods and services in 18 jurisdictions worldwide
Data Privacy Alert: California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 Just Enacted
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Litigation Financing Confidentiality and Marijuana Ethics For Lawyers
U.S. Markets See First Cannabis IPO
NYS Department of Financial Services Issues Guidance to Banks on Servicing the Marijuana Industry
THSH Cyber Alert: GoDaddy the latest to leave S3 Bucket Unsecured
Legalized Adult-Use Marijuana Coming to New York?
NYS and NYC Sexual Harassment Prevention Laws
Are Your Website and Privacy Policy GDPR Compliant?
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Ethics and Best Practices For Law School Clinics
Beware of the AIA Form of Performance Bond
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Referral Fees and Using a Client as an Expert
Anecdotes from World’s Largest B2B Cannabis Conference
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Restrictive Covenants In Agreements Employing Lawyers
Turndown Service with that Hack: Marriott Hotels Announce Massive Data Breach
Attorney Professionalism Forum: Handling Confidential Client Information
Groundbreaking 2018 Farm Bill Portends Huge Changes to U.S. Cannabis and Hemp Industries
Attorney Professionalism Forum: The Challenges of Litigating Against Pro Se Parties
Articles By Topic
HRMinute
Cyber & Privacy Alert
New York Law Journal
Attorney Professionalism Forum
Join Our Mailing List
Publication
Like us on FaceBook Follow us on Twitter Get LinkedIn with us Pin It! Email Us Print this Page

Sitemap |Terms of Use | Privacy | Attorney Advertising

Tannenbaum Helpern Syracuse & Hirschtritt LLP provides legal advice only to individuals or entities with which it has established an attorney-client relationship and such advice is based on the particular facts and circumstances of each matter. Contacting us through this site, or otherwise, will not establish an attorney-client relationship with us. Any e-mail or other communication sent to THSH or its lawyers through this site will not be treated as subject to the attorney-client privilege or as otherwise confidential and you should not include any confidential information in any such communication.