Tannenbaum Helpern Syracuse & Hirschtritt, LLP
About Us Careers Contact Us Search
Home Practice Areas Industries Case Results Attorneys Publications Events Press Room

Second Circuit Extends Safe Harbor Protection to Creditors’ State Law Claims

On March 29, 2016, the Second Circuit held that Section 546(e) of the Bankruptcy Code preempts state law claims by creditors seeking to recover certain constructively fraudulent transfers made in connection with a securities contract. In re Tribune Co. Fraudulent Conveyance Lit., 2016 WL 1226871 (2d Cir. Mar. 29, 2016). Section 546(e) explicitly bars such claims by a bankruptcy trustee, but the Second Circuit ruling in Tribune extends its “safe harbor” protections to claims brought by creditors and their representatives. The ruling therefore provides transferees with additional protections by further limiting plaintiffs’ claw back rights with respect to certain constructively fraudulent transfers.

A constructive fraudulent transfer is a transfer of property for less than reasonably equivalent value made at a time when the transferor is insolvent, or where it becomes insolvent as a result of the transfer. A bankruptcy trustee is empowered to avoid and recover such transfers so long as they are made within two years of the filing of the bankruptcy petition. However, Section 546(e) provides transferees with a safe harbor by precluding the recovery of such transfers so long as they were margin or settlement payments made by specified financial transferors in connection with a securities contract.

The appellants in Tribune were unsecured creditors who sought to recover moneys received by former shareholders in connection with a Leveraged Buyout. The appellants argued that, while Section 546(e) precluded such constructive fraudulent transfer claims by the trustee under the Bankruptcy Code, it did not bar such claims by creditors brought pursuant to state law. The Second Circuit rejected their argument, finding that their state constructive fraudulent transfer claims were preempted by Section 546(e). In reaching its conclusion, the Second Circuit noted the strong federal interest in regulating creditors’ rights and the securities markets, as well as the practical difficulties of barring such claims by a trustee only to allow unsecured creditors to assert the same claims instead.

The ruling in Tribune provides transferees with additional certainty by applying the safe harbor protections of Section 546(e) to constructive fraudulent transfer claims made by creditors pursuant to state law. While the Second Circuit did not rule on the ability of creditors to bring state law claims arising from transfers beyond the scope of Section 546(e), the holding of Tribune is a welcome development for securities investors and securities markets.

For more information on the topic discussed, contact Wayne H. Davis at davis@thsh.com or at 212-508-6705 or Richard W. Trotter at trotter@thsh.com or at 212-508-7542.


About Tannenbaum Helpern Syracuse & Hirschtritt LLP

Since 1978, Tannenbaum Helpern Syracuse & Hirschtritt LLP has combined a powerful mix of insight, creativity, industry knowledge, senior talent and transaction expertise to successfully guide clients through periods of challenge and opportunity. Our mission is to deliver the highest quality legal services in a practical and efficient manner, bringing to bear the judgment, common sense and expertise of well trained, business minded lawyers. Through our commitment to service and successful results, Tannenbaum Helpern continues to earn the loyalty of our clients and a reputation for excellence. For more information, visit www.thsh.com. Follow us on LinkedIn and Twitter: @THSHLAW.

Like us on FaceBook Follow us on Twitter Get LinkedIn with us Pin It! Email Us Print this Page

Sitemap | Terms of Use | Privacy | Attorney Advertising

Tannenbaum Helpern Syracuse & Hirschtritt LLP provides legal advice only to individuals or entities with which it has established an attorney-client relationship and such advice is based on the particular facts and circumstances of each matter. Contacting us through this site, or otherwise, will not establish an attorney-client relationship with us. Any e-mail or other communication sent to THSH or its lawyers through this site will not be treated as subject to the attorney-client privilege or as otherwise confidential and you should not include any confidential information in any such communication.